Choices--Breeder Pup or Gorgeous Adult

Poedogruns said:
I never considered that the close proximity in age might mean a battle for top dog between the two. My perfect scenario would be the dogs would best friends that play well. Maybe this isn't certain with an older dog match?
Click to expand...
Most Shelties get along well but it is something to think on.
 
When I decided at 10 months old that Bacca needed a companion pup....I went instantly to getting an older dog. At 10 months, I was still close enough to remember how painful puppies can be if you can't be there 24 x 7. So I opted for Indy who was also 10 months old.

One thing to remember....we all love puppies, but they dont' last long! I would suggest a trial with the older dog and see how they get along, if that's possibile.

It really does depend on your lifestyle. I think I could get a puppy now because I my day life supports it. But I couldn't then.
 
Emma will be four in September, Liam four in December, and Natalie three in May. Emma I got at 9 weeks, Liam at about 10 months, and Natalie at about 10 months. There is no question that Emma is top dog in the house. Liam is just so happy to lucky he gets along with both girls. Natalie tries to take over sometimes but she gets put in her place by Emma - snarls and teeth sometimes but not often. This has been my experience at getting an older pup. Just consider what your needs are for your other two and weigh the pros and cons of an older dog or a pup.
 
Well, I just got Brooke, a retired 7 year old show dog. Now, my other two girls are 11, and I didn't need a playmate for anyone. But as unlikely as it may seem, all 3 girls get along FINE. None of them is an alpha. They are all 3 easy-going dogs.

So I say it depends on the dogs as to whether they will get along. We did a 2 week trial period with Brooke and it was evident pretty quickly that it would work out great. Margi is another SN member who got an adult 5 yr old to go along with her half-grown puppy.

With a pup, they still might not get along, no guarantees. Of course puppies are adorable to offset the craziness of raising them!! :biggrin2:

I would at least give the adult dog serious consideration. My 2 cents worth.
 
Reading this my gut says try out the 3 yr old first if you can. It could be an instant win win if she is playful, same energy level, etc. The puppy will be 4 months out before coming home and probably longer before being a reasonable playmate for a two yr old.

Koko at 5 doesn't "play" with Fillion (6 months) the way I had hoped, but he had been officially nominated for sainthood. That puppy chews his ears, slams his toys in his face, and his latest is to grab his front legs as he tries to walk. But he is companionship and a definite calming influence on his rowdy boy.

And Tabitha, it is really cool to say "Yes, this is father and son" on our walks:lol:
 
Just because she is a UKC CH doesnt mean she isnt also AKC registered. I cant think of anyone who strictly registers Shelties UKC only. If a dog is only registered with one, they would be only AKC registered. Some who show UKC will have dual registered dogs, but I never see only UKC.
If this is a blue, I know who the three year old is though havent met the dog in person. If it is this dog, she is dual registered.
 
Last edited:
Lucky you to have choices. I am happy I have an older dog only because having a 93 year old to look after I was afraid a puppy would create danger and falling and I didnt think I had the energy for the training with all I have to do, That said I see these puppies and my heartstrings are pulled. A little furry baby to watch grow and love is pretty special. You have one tough choice, but again having choices is wonderful. Good luck whatever you decide, either way it looks like you win to me.
 
Just going over to the Puppies 101 has been motivating, lol.

I think I am leaning toward the older dog. I wouldn't have the hassle of potty training and leash training. I will immediately be able to talk long walks with her and work her slowly into my daily jogging routine.

Cuteness aside, this sounds like the least stressful situation for me, the other animals in the house, my husband (who loves the dogs, but doesn't love living in toilet).

Love to get them both, but daily expense wise (quality food, etc) and limited space/time issues would prevent that from happening.

Thanks so much for all the comments. Its been very helpful in guiding me in this decision.
 
HopeShelties said:
Just because she is a UKC CH doesnt mean she isnt also AKC registered. I cant think of anyone who strictly registers Shelties UKC only. If a dog is only registered with one, they would be only AKC registered. Some who show UKC will have dual registered dogs, but I never see only UKC.
If this is a blue, I know who the three year old is though havent met the dog in person. If it is this dog, she is dual registered.
Click to expand...

All of my dogs are dual registered with AKC/UKC. UKC focuses more on the total dog in philosopy. Conformation and working ability or as they put it conformation, temperment and function.

The dog are judged in theory more of functional conformation than AKC. No product is allow in the coat, no fancy sculpting grooming is allowed and no professional handlers. CHW are allowed in shelties. It is a small registery but I really like their philosopy. I just wish more people would show with them.

Of my dog, Justice is A UKC Grand Champion, UKC Grand Obedience Champion, and UKC Agility Champion. Ember is UKC CH, Agility II and UKC UD dog, Diva is A UKC Ch and Agility II dog and Birch has his UKC Agility II title.

I started in UKC Obedience long ago with my JRT mix as UKC allowed mix breeds to show before any other registeration(partnered with the old AMBOR). So they will always be close to my heart. IMO UKC Utility is the most difficult obedience class in the US. I know many AKC OTCH who couldn't Q in it.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top