What breeds do Shelties get along with?

LOL, I'm not surprised you have strong feelings on the matter, "labgirl" ;-)

I don't believe that labs are stupid, rough, or any more annoying than any other sporting breed--I was mostly commenting on the commonness of the breed, and how everyone feels the need to have a lab, and often not for any particular reason except that it's what other people have. If shelties were as common as Labrador retrievers, you can be sure that I would get something else--no matter how much I liked them, lol--like a Belgian shepherd or a Icelandic shepherd...I've been known for a tendency toward Hype Aversion. I should also mention that I tend not to find sporting dogs very appealing in general; my mother's Gordon setters, even if they're nicer looking imo, have that same stubborn streak and they drive me nuts--as well as the super-friendly attitude that, while most people like it, I tend to find off-putting. I think the sheltie breeder was surprised when I was interested initially in a female dog because they were less outgoing and friendly.

Not to mention the slobber...and slobber...and more slobber. -.-;; if a dog was very attractive and stubborn, I'd probably be willing to put up with it...or if a dog was less attractive but tractable, I might be willing to put up with it...but a dog who is both stubborn with big, floppy lips just won't do it for me.

Ultimately, my dislike of labs (besides said hype aversion, though like I said, I tend not to like sporting dogs in general) is just a matter of personal preference. :-)

Hehe, yes I am pretty biased! But of course I understand we all have our own tastes in dogs - be a boring old world if we didn't! Then again, some of the things you list as disadvantages in a lab are what I see as their charms - but I guess I would :wink2:

Of course, I'm loitering on here because I'm planning that the next dog be a blue merle sheltie and I'm doing my research at the moment on the breed - so far nothing puts me off. :smile2:

As for breeds of dog that I don't like - well I could happily live in a world without terriers, but only because so many of them around here are so snappy and aggressive.

And I'm frightened of border collies, but I need to get over that as my brother is a trainee sheep farmer and will have working BCs eventually.
 
Lots of great discussion here, I just kind of skimmed so I apologize if I'm repeating what anyone else has already said :wink2:

My husband and I live in a Sheltie/Australian Shepherd household and, while I love my boys we are planning to expand to 4 with 1 more sheltie and 1 more aussie, I wouldn't necessarily recommend this combo to others. Our aussie Apollo has more drive than any dog I've ever met, and if we don't keep him exercised and occupied with jobs he is far too rough a playmate for Smoke. When the 2 of them start playing I have to watch them carefully and be ready to separate them at a second's notice.

Now, my mom has a Great Pyrenees and Smoke absolutely loves being with her. The Pyr is extremely gentle. She understands just what kind of play Smoke can handle and keeps it at that level herself. I think she might think hes her puppy :biggrin2: Smoke also loves my mother in laws Samoyed and our neighbor's Golden Retriever. Other big dogs that Smoke knows and gets along well with are a Standard Poodle and a Greater Swiss Mountain Dog.

I think that if you want to add a bigger dog to your household then easygoing breeds are the way to go. Intense, drivey breeds like Border Collies and Aussies are probably going to be too much for the sheltie unless you are willing to spend a lot of time managing them. And of course, a lot of it will be the individual new dog's personality. I hear there are easygoing Aussies, I've just never met one lol.

Whatever breed you decide to go with, best of luck with your new addition!!
 
Thanks Julie D! Another win for the Pyrs!! :biggrin2:

I have found 2 breeders in the North Island here in NZ, the only 2 I could find - and they are 6-8 hours driving away!! We're visiting family out of the country for a month in August so Im hoping beyond hope that one of them will have a litter ready shortly after that!
 
What about a Boxer? My Boxer and Sheltie get along great..................... and the Pug, but you said bigger.

Best thing of all, it gives my little Sheltie puppy a chance to "roll his eyes" when the boxer does something stupid...............................daily.
 
I think a lot of it depends on each individual dog, as well. From personal experience, my sheltie has snubbed a poodle. He refused to even look at her at the vet the other day. :lol: Also, I think maybe schnauzers would be too much. I've only met one before, and it was completely wired up. It was nice and friendly, but I think that might have been too much for a more laid back sheltie. My uncle's pomeranian tried to attack my dog, so I'm not sure about those either. My aunt and uncle have always had pomeranians, and they're always extremely friendly to people, but they don't seem to apperciate other dogs coming into their home.

It's hard to say this breed would go good with this dog and this breed wouldn't. Each dog is different, and dogs are raised differently. What might be a good match for one dog might not be a good match for another.

You could always just get another sheltie. :winkgrin:
 
I'm quite late to this thread so this may be moot.

When we had our first Sheltie we also had a German Shepherd. We got them two weeks apart at 8 weeks old each. They grew up together.

At first the Sheltie had the upper hand, despite the size difference. Shep puppies are so incredibly clumsy and our little Sheltie literally ran circles around the GS. We used to laugh so hard because the Sheltie would race around the room and stand behind the GS, while the GS was scanning the room looking for her. Then of course, the size equation changed. Our Sheltie was not shy about letting her big sister know when she had been too rough. It was a non-issue except for one single behavior. Our GS would take her paw and roll the Sheltie over and that didn't go over well. It was the only time we ever saw our Sheltie snarl and mean it. The GS would look confused as if to say, What did I do?. There was really never a problem in which we had to interfere.

The Sheltie was the dominant one in that relationship. Even the boarding kennel would tell us our Sheltie was in charge with one caveat, they always took the GS out first because if anyone reached for the Sheltie they found out just how protective a GS could be.

If we had the room and were younger (we're retired), we would have gotten another GS too. These are the two breeds I love to no end.
 
lol
I agree with everything that has been said around Poodles... They are easy to train, high energy and easygoing, if you give them enough exercise and actually work with them, to work off some hyper issues lol
Also any gentle breed with NO prey drive...
On the other hand I would go with another Sheltie, like who am I kidding... that breed is IT for me now...

I had a GSD and a Boxer, but the Boxer was there first. The male GSD was kind of hard on the older Boxer Lady because of age and clumsiness. He eventually became the Alpha, and although it was fine for the dogs, it broke MY heart, to see the Boxer Lady de-throned, and her being deferential to the "big oaf" even tho they never even fought!

So I had to respect that, to keep the peace and pet him first, etc, so she then bonded more with my husband even though she had always been MY shadow, but apparently I came with that position, like a prize...

So, those are two larger breeds, and similar in a lot of ways, imagine what a badly paired match could do to your lil Sheltie?
 
So, those are two larger breeds, and similar in a lot of ways, imagine what a badly paired match could do to your lil Sheltie?

Here are the pairs that my friends have.
Rottweiler and shelties
Malamute and shelties
Mini dashshund and shelties
Border collie and shelties
Lab mix and Shelties

In all cases the shelties get along with the other dogs. They seem to just go with the flow based on the temperment of the other dog. Although with large breed dogs you do have to be careful because they shear size can injure the sheltie if they play too rough. My friends Mal stepped on her puppy when he was 12 wks old and cracked his fibia. They were chasing each other( 3 shelties and the mal) the shelties turned the mal couldn't and ran over the puppy. No aggression just physics.:(The pups leg heal fine. :smile2:
 
Hehehe...well, I'll throw a vote in for the collie/sheltie combo, not that I'm biased or anying :biggrin2: Of course, it makes for a lot of hair floating around the house. A lot. Which is why I'm coveting a smooth collie for our next household addition :smile2: Oh and the whole having to explain that they are not 'mom and pup' if I walk them together :lol: :lol:
 
Back
Top