Megansmom may have been referring to my father, as I've mentioned this on different ocassions. He was feeding Lucy Beneful before I got here. He honestly thought it was good for her. But honestly, his dogs live long, healthy lives. He's never had one with cancer, diabetes, seizures or anything else. They just live until they're old and can't go on any longer. I don't know how to argue with that, but I continue to feed Meggie, and now Lucy, high quality food. They are on Wellness Whitefish and Sweet Potato now. They love it. I always augment with vegis too.