I am glad y'all found something that works. I did a quick read of the ingredients and it has rosemary. Rosemary is what my previous sheltie reacted to. She would have a seizure with anything that included that -20 mins after ingesting anything with it, and she would fall over and seize. If you google it you can see it is a neurotoxin and can cause neurological issues in some pets, including cats. Just be careful, because for some shelties it can be toxic. I lived this and it was horrible, I wouldn't want anyone to go through it. The FDA has stated it is not a concern, really? All I can say is my sheltie suffered. Her previous food didn't contain it, the substitute food I got did, and she had issues with it every time she ate anything containing it. When she didn't have that reaction EVER before. Then any time she got another product that had it, it would happen. Milkbones, treats, etc. Deduction showed it was an issue. Herbalist and Holistic practitioners STATE herbs are medicinal, and shouldn't be used as flavoring randomly for those who have sensitivities or allergies. Shelties tend to be rather sensitive and are prone to allergic reactions so it stands to reason they fall into that "exception" group. Other dogs I knew starting exhibiting the same types of reaction when it became widespread in the pet food industry to stick it in foods and treats as a preservative. Just because some can tolerate it, doesn't discount those that can't, and MANY can't. And I can't think of ANY dogs in the wild that would ingest herbs as a normal dietary ingredient. Grand Mal seizures are frightening. If there is NO history of seizures or epilepsy then suddenly, when eating rosemary infused food stuff there is now a problem with epilepsy, it makes perfect sense that the link exists. If you look on different dog sites, especially in smaller breeds, it is more than coincidence. Maybe the scientific community couldn't find a link. But in my experience, with people I knew, we certainly discovered evidence.